Here is the transcript of the Roots and All podcast based on the provided source:
Sarah Wilson: This is the Roots and All Podcast, and I’m your host, Sarah Wilson. Join me as I talk about all aspects of gardening with some of the top horticulturists from around the world. This week, I’m joined by botanist and naturalist Joey Santore, whose infectious curiosity about the plant world has made him a distinctive voice in botanical education.We talk about the importance of understanding plants in the context of the ecosystems they evolved in, why native plants matter, and the ecological consequences of moving species around the world. We also get into the increasingly heated debate around native and invasive plants, and why a better understanding of ecology might help us see the bigger picture.
Joey Santore: I got into botany and I started—I mean, I realized how important photographs were, so I’m always taking photos to document everything because that’s—that’s basically, I mean, so much data can be contained in a photo, you know, if you’ve got if you know what to take pictures of. So I’ve—I created, um, I’ve got a database, you know, full of photos, both on iNaturalist and on my, on my photocloud, that I then use for presentations or for making photo books, or, uh, if I’m giving lectures, you know, I was teaching college botany for a semester, uh, a couple of years ago. It was really helpful then because I could show pictures, you know, illustrations of of, um, morphological and ecological phenomena that I, you know, like extrafloral nectaries, or, you know, a certain anther type that I could then show people. I, you know, had examples of all the photos. So I’m always taking photos, documenting things that way, um, trying to create records, especially of rare plants or plants that are not very, very well known. Um, and then, you know, for the video stuff I do, that just started on YouTube. It was just me sharing, uh, adventures I had going out and looking at, at plants that I was interested in and then showing people the plants and then the habitat, and then explaining why they were why they were interesting or worth paying attention to and what was notable about them.
Joey Santore: Right? More more so than just, you know, I can make a herbal potion out of it, uh, that can theoretically cure me of some ailment that I may not have, um, and more than just like, oh, it’s psychoactive if you, you know, smoke it or something like that. And more focus on what what is this like what’s unique about this plant? How does it behave? Plants behave all the time. How does it behave in an ecosystem? What what what animals does it interact with, um, why, you know, how did it evolve this way and how is that the way that it evolved tied to the habitat that it evolved in, which there’s always a huge tie in there. Um, and then just trying to share that with people because it was for me, it was very, uh, medicating, because I grew up, you know, getting thrown out of schools, getting in fights, getting beat up, uh, you know, um, getting in trouble with cops, I mean, all kind, you know, fun stuff, stuff that’s good for kids, I think, right? It’s better than I mean, that’s a better alternative than just following the rules your whole life and, you know, now realizing what you missed out on till you’re 50 or 60 years old and then regretting it. Um, so I had, you know, I had a very, um, controversial childhood and was pretty angry, got into punk rock. Uh, and then when I found the living work and I kind of had a problem with like people in groups and with, you know, society and stuff. Humans aren’t an inherently conformist species. There’s there’s very little intellectual and independent thought, um, depending on what culture you’re in. Most cultures there’s not much of that. Um, and especially in this, this kind of like late-stage capitalism culture that most of the first world is, the the quote-unquote Anglosphere and much of Latin America, um, you know, it’s very dehumanizing, it’s a consumer culture, it worships money, it’s very wealth-worshipping, it worships the sociopaths, um, you know, among us, and those are the people that get in positions of power, and so there’s always generally a void of leadership at the top, and so I noticed this really early on and, um, it led me to, you know, generally have negative feelings about most things in human society.
Joey Santore: And when I found, quote-unquote nature—I don’t even like that word—when I found nature or the living world, it was a a pleasant distraction from it. It was a really pleasant distraction and it was so fascinating and it seemed like all the answers I had been looking for were right there, um, including, you know, how how my own existence came into being, geologic time scale, stuff like that. I wanted to And so I wanted to share that with other people. When I found that I wanted to share it with other people, I thought it was really therapeutic and also kind of drew people out of this really narrow, myopic, parochial, um, setting that most of us are raised in. So, uh, so that’s what I do. And so that’s what I started sharing with people, and then basically my whole life revolves around that, around plants now in some form or another. You know, whether I’m making art, or whether I’m, whether when I’m traveling, I’m always looking at what’s growing in places, et cetera.
Sarah Wilson: I think what you were saying is you were kind of drawn to plants because it is escapism from maybe a world that’s very materialistic, very conformist, got a lot of rules and regulations. Do you think that plants kind of aren’t like that, or do you think there is the opportunity to politicize plants?
Joey Santore: No, there’s no opportunity to politicize plants. It’s all human. It’s all human constructs. It’s it’s and, the, I mean plants are like the most apolitical thing, I think, in the world. I mean they’re they’re, you know, all that they’re so removed from anthropomorphizing and from people. People try to do it all the time, but the more you learn, the more you the more you learn about plants, the more you realize how absurd it is, and you realize how, you know, you realize how unique humans are in many respects, the way we we look at things. I mean, we’ve got a very myopic view on the world and a very short-term view as well because our lives are so short.
Joey Santore: You know, and the more I travel, the more I understand this. But I mean that’s so plants are escapism, but they’re they’re also literally the answer and, you know, I said that before. All the answers I’ve been looking for were here, they they really are. Plants and and just life in general, studying life on Earth.
Sarah Wilson: And yet we do actually sometimes try and bring political agendas and our egos into plants, don’t we? Particularly, I think, when we’re talking about plants that are native to a particular eco-region or plants that might be
Joey Santore: No, yeah, if they’re morons, definitely. I see that happening all the time. That’s definitely a moronic thing I see. People, you know, especially with like with with native plants, you hear people saying that all the time, that’s xenophobia or whatever, but that’s I mean that’s the most absurd thing, because every every invasive plant is a very important plant somewhere else. It’s a member of an ecosystem. But when you learn how ecosystems evolve and how speciation evolves, I mean that’s like that’s number one in evolutionary biology, right? For speciation to occur, you need isolation, right? But it’s not just speciation, it’s for an ecosystem to evolve, it it evolves isolated from another ecosystem, generally by large oceans or on other sides of continents or vast mountain ranges or whatever. And so when you take a species that evolved in a in a disparate location and you move it across 3,000 miles of ocean overnight, um, well, understanding that every plant is tied to its ecosystem, it’s not just an autonomous entity, it’s kept in check by, uh, fungi and insects primarily and, and herbivores and other things, macro-herbivores. And then the more you learn about that, the more you learn, wow, this is really like a well-oiled machine, the ecosystem, and, um, and when you take a piece from one machine and try to make it work in another machine, uh, a lot of times it doesn’t work. Sometimes it works and and doesn’t really work, it doesn’t really, not really works, but it’ll not be harmful, it’s not going to cause the machine to fall apart, you know, where you’re just sticking a piece out and jamming it in to another one. But sometimes it does, right? Like that’s what chestnut blight. That’s what happened with chestnut blight. We took an invasive fungus that evolved 9,000 miles away in an ecosystem where it wasn’t a big problem because it evolved there slowly over 9 or 10 million years with its host plant Chinese chestnut, and then you move it to an ecosystem where it didn’t evolve and it kills every last living chestnut, or makes it functionally extinct. There’s still chestnuts, but they don’t get big on the East Coast. You can grow them out west where there’s less humidity, good western North America, uh, because the fungus needs humidity to to fruit, warmth and humidity, um, there’s never you know, summers are not humid out west. Um, but, you know, in the Eastern United States, it’s it’s killed everything. Every every tree pathogen we have in North America is an invasive species of fungus or insect. So it kind of blows my mind. I mean this is like a well-studied thing. This is just basic ecology, this is evolution, it’s tied to long spans of time, but it kind of blows my mind to hear people that deny invasion biology, whether it’s like some stupid woke identity politics or or not, you know, which those were a psyop of course, I always enjoy bringing that up, there was a psyop to distract people from class.
Joey Santore: Of course, social context is important, um, to have, and racism is very real, but racism is idiotic as hell, too. Um, but, you know, the whole identity politics thing, tying that to plants, those are human constructs, you know, I think generally well-inten- well-intentioned, but they’ve gone a little mentally ill in the last few years, uh, and this is one this is one indication of that. Tying tying, you know, human xenophobia and trying to tie that into an understanding of ecosystems is complete madness. It’s and it’s I mean it’s just ignorance. It’s not it’s not even madness, I shouldn’t say that. It’s ignorance. It’s it’s ignorance. The madness comes in when you don’t know how much you don’t know, and you start of making these extrapolations that people who are against invasive plants, because they don’t want to see their ecosystem wrecked, somehow ties in to some of the racist bullshit you hear. I hear they have a lot of that in the UK, don’t they? They’ve got all this stuff, all these people are ruining it, right? It’s all we have the same fucking nonsense here. It’s really easy for right-wing politicians to play with because that plays into people’s emotions when you don’t have anything else to offer people, you play on culture issues and immigration and work that up, and it’s an easy wedge issue. That’s what what made Trump such a, you know, a successful conman, right? But, but when you look at ecosystems and how they evolve, you realize, well, these are really important plants. There’s no there’s no comparison to humans that would be insane, right? I mean you you like go and look at like things in your kitchen, kitchen condiments and start comparing those to human society. It’d be the same thing. It’s that’s where the mental illness comes in, right? Um, when you look at these ecosystems and you realize that these let’s literally what it is, you’re taking pieces from a machine that have evolved together over 9 million years and you you put it somewhere else. I mean, that’s what that’s what happened with Native Americans and and smallpox, right? European societies and Eurasian societies had evolved with smallpox over tens of thousands of years and it caused a lot of death, but slowly over time they were able some of them were able to survive it. Then you bring it to a novel population of the same species, human beings, and, you know, that’s been separated from those other populations for 30, 40,000 years, perhaps longer, we’re learning human beings have been in North America a lot longer than we initially thought. Uh, and and they have no resistance to it, and it starts it just kills, on that’s the same thing that happened with I mean it’s to deny this is like denying climate change. It’s like it’s like denying that CO2 traps heat. Uh, it’s crazy. So I it’s kind of hard for me to believe that this still goes on. I mean, sure, when I was like 15 years old and and learned, you know, read people’s history of the United States and just learned what what atrocities the country I live in committed, maybe and I didn’t know anything about biology, botany, or evolution yet, maybe I would be like this is horrible, this is the same thing people do with human beings, you know, and fear of immigration. But then the more you learn, you’re like, oh no, actually, these ecosystems that are separated, actually there’s not plants have not just moved everywhere over time, which is what they always say. Everything’s everything was invasive at some point. Well, no, not really. It’s not how it goes. Dispersal events, as they’re called, you know, like a dispersal of a seed across an ocean was actually very rare in the history of, um, you know, say the last 40 million years, which is not that much time, but last 40 million years. And where it’s occurred and been successful and that plant has gotten established, you know, we can document it using molecular clock dating, you know, DNA, and and see it. And it turns out it actually hasn’t happened as much as people like to say.
Joey Santore: And especially not much in the last 8 or 9 million years, which is really the amount of time since, you know, Eurasia and North America have been disconnected, right? Because during warmer pre- you know, the heavy Miocene cooling, like the last however many millions of years, a couple million years of ice age. Before that, you know, the higher latitudes were warm enough and so things, you know, when there were forests, not boreal forests, but you know, woodlands growing at woodlands that are now much lower in latitude were growing at higher latitudes, you know, up at the towards the North Pole, things could move easily between, you know, Asia and and North America. But then as the ice age set in and it cooled, things got cut off, right? The the the freeze line came down. And so Eurasia and and North America got separated. And so like that’s for like American chestnuts and Chinese chestnuts, it’s like presumed, I think when I looked into it, looking at a phylogeny, that they’d last shared a common ancestor around 9 to 12 million years ago, which so that means that since then, Chinese chestnut and the chestnut blight were evolving, uh, you know, in the same place, sympatrically.
Joey Santore: And so that’s why Chinese chestnut slowly built up a resistance to it, you know, the fungus would get a little virulent, attack the Chinese chestnut, the chestnut, you know, large portion of the population would die, some wouldn’t because of phenotypic variation, they had resistance to to the blight. They would build up resistance. Those now those now individuals were the ones breeding and forming new seedlings, new progeny, and then the virus the the maybe the the blight, the fungus would get a little bit more virulent and so on. Boom, boom, boom. It was an evolutionary arms race, right? This is something that people would learn if they cracked open, uh, you know, ecology or evolution textbooks before they opened their mouths about this. So, um, I mean it’s just it’s just the way things work on planet Earth, right? And it’s but now we’re going to lead eventually probably to a more homogenized, uh, a more homogenized ecosystem on planet Earth, and lots of things are going to go extinct. And one of the ways they’re going to go extinct is by invasive species.
Joey Santore: So, I mean people who who don’t like it and who think who’s somehow you can’t equate it to people. You just can’t. That would be insane. That’s like using the mentality of a nine-year-old. No offense to them, right? You just the more you learn, the more you’re like, oh, actually there’s a method to this madness and it’s not just people slapping, uh, you know, arbitrary definitions on things. And also, yeah, racism is bad, and, you know, anti-immigrant has historically been used as a really easy wedge issue to manipulate working-class people into not, uh, going after the people who are actually oppressing them, and instead going after immigrants, right? You got to build class solidarity. Class solidarity, which goes which transcends the boundaries of race. I’m fucking talking for a long time. I apologize, right? Race doesn’t exist, it’s not a real thing. Whatever.
Sarah Wilson: What concerns me is that there is very much an argument here in the UK at least for kind of things like assisted migration, and there is a line that gets trotted out a lot, which is that, I think by 2050 in London we’re going to have the same climate that Barcelona has now. So they’re saying they’re predicting all these temperature increases, and what they’re trying to do is get ahead of those problems by planting species that aren’t native, but are maybe from the same kind of eco-region. That it’s like they’re predicting the climate change and therefore predicting what they’re planting to cope with it. And I think that so much of what we do comes from a place of absolutely zero knowledge or very little knowledge, and it’s speculation. And it concerns me that we’re saying, you know, we’re already signing the death warrant of our native species by saying they’re not going to adapt to climate change, therefore we should just get
Joey Santore: Well, it’s not it’s not a death warrant. Things are going to move north, and we see the same thing happening here. And I see, you know, that when you look at the proximity of, you know, say parts of Southern Europe to the UK, it’s not the same as say if people were like, well, let’s let’s plant grows in Chicago, so let’s just bring it over to to the UK because, you know, we’re fucked anyway. Like that, you know, I know our native goldenrod, which I love, is really invasive in Europe, along with a bunch of of other, you know, wonderful plants I, right? And so that could cause ecosystem collapse, bringing something from that far away that produces tons of seeds and doesn’t have as many. Goldenrod’s got so many things to keep it in check here. Solidago does, like so many insects use it, right? And a lot of those insects probably aren’t in Europe, which is why it just, I mean it’s prolific here. It’s probably a nightmare over there.
Joey Santore: Um, you know, but if, but taking something from like 300 miles to the south, 500 miles to the south,
Sarah Wilson: Well, they would argue that if it was from a sort of similar latitude, that it would be okay. They would say, you know, let’s take this across the globe and, you know, our climate would be similar to somewhere south of maybe New York. So they would say, okay, well, anything along that parallel is fair game to introduce.
Joey Santore: That’s ignorant, though, because they’re ignoring that huge vicariance barrier, that huge ecological barrier, i.e., the Atlantic Ocean that’s been separating those ecosystems for millions of years. So it’s ignorant. They’re not looking at all the factors, right? You’re just going to look at something that’s from the same climate. I mean, that’s completely ignorant. That doesn’t make any sense. You’re not looking That’d be like being a doctor and trying to like figure out, uh, you know, a diagnosis for a patient without looking at everything that’s afflicting that patient, without taking in all the symptoms and all the other factors that, you know, it’s it’s just doesn’t make any sense. Like it’s not just same climate. You have to look at the whole the whole cast of ecological checks and balances. This is why ecology is such an important, which is a very recent science, like last 100 years it’s been around, really, and less than that, right?
Joey Santore: Like China was doing their great green wall project 40 years ago. They were planting shit that wasn’t native to China. It just fucking boggles the mind. And they suppose they fixed it, they realized, oh, we can’t do this, right? It didn’t evolve here. It’s either not going to survive or it’s going to survive too well because nothing keeps it in check. But the more you know, the more you know, the more you know. Holy shit, I didn’t realize there’s the only reason that this certain plant that I really like isn’t taking over is because it evolved here over millions of years and it’s got like 17 different species of insects that, you know, keep it in check, that literally, you know, act like mowers and prevent it from over overtaking, right? Or that maybe, you know, it’s if it’s a fungus or there’s a fungus on it that could be brought in too, that also attacks things that we like here, that, uh, you know, grows with related it’s a minor parasite on related things in this ecosystem, but when you take it 4,000 miles away across an ocean from an to an ecosystem it’s never been in, right? Now it’s it attacks things in the same evolutionary lineage, family or genus, whatever, that don’t have any resistance to it, right? I mean, it’s just it’s it’s madness. It’s a really it’s mad I mean, not knowing is fine, but once someone tells you and you’re still like, well, fuck it, you know, I I just like it. I like the way it looks. I mean, that’s madness. That’s fucking moronic.
Joey Santore: So and that’s what’s causing I mean
Sarah Wilson: Invasive species are one of the the largest causes of of extinction right now.
Joey Santore: Again, we have this issue here where people are pushing back against the term invasive, and I do understand, you know, it can be divisive. But I wonder from your point of view, are you more a conservationist in terms of trying to keep an ecosystem functioning as it did at a particular point in time, or are you more kind of hands off, okay, let’s see how this novel ecosystem develops?
Joey Santore: Time has nothing to do with it. That’s another like strawman argument people that deny invasion biology always use. Like, well, you have to go back to period 600 years ago? Well, no, it’s got nothing to do with it. You’re just again, you’re not thinking about you’re uneducated in what you’re arguing about. It’s not about time, it’s about did it like the only reason, you know, that that looking at time as a reference is because it evolved here. It’s an indication that it evolved here. It evolved before humans started oceanic transport to to the exponential degree that they have and started swapping shit from one ecosystem to another one 9,000 miles away. That’s the only reason time is the only reason in 1491 is the is like the point at which we look at, right? We’re never going to get back to that. You’re never going to get back to that, but you want to look at how does this behave in an ecosystem, right? And the other thing people say is, well, you’re never going to get all of it. You’re never going to get this invasive plant, you’re never going to get all of it. There are are manageable forms of leukemia, right? That that aren’t going to kill you if you take a pill. You can take a pill, you could live with this cancer for the next 40 years of your fucking life. Right? You take this pill every day, it’s manageable. But if you stop taking the pill, you’re going to die in a number of years, in a couple years. Would you tell it’s the same thing with invasive species? Would you tell people to stop taking the pill because they’re never going to get all of it? That would be fucking moronic, too. That would be insane. So, again, these arguments, I think it’s it’s people who have no self-awareness, some of them, not all of them, maybe some of them are well-intentioned, who just like a plant or like something or or have a certain view of the world that isn’t rooted in reality, ecological reality, and they want to cling to that view of the world. But you don’t need to do that, right? It’s like it’s the same thing with creationists. Like you can be religious and admit that evolution’s real, like your book doesn’t tell you that you have to deny, you know, that fucking humans and chimps share a common ancestor to be pious. You can be a very pious person and still not be a moron and admit that evolution’s real and we can study it, right? You can love plants and admit that some plants you love, and there’s a lot of invasive species I love, I just don’t love them where they’re invasive. You can love plants and and still admit that like, yeah, this is an issue to, you know, take this plant over here and it’s going to fucking get crazy. I love cacti. I don’t want to bring them back to Australia, right? Prickly pears, I mean that was a you saw what happened, that’s like a famous ecological case study. So I think people really it really is a case of the more you know. The more you know and the less afraid of, you know, admitting you might have been wrong at one point that you are, which is the mark of a mature human being, right? It’s once you realize like I don’t need to just maintain this ego status for my semi-conscious simian relatives, uh, then you can grow as a person. So, yeah.
Sarah Wilson: So, how important do you feel gardens are in terms of providing habitat and also how responsible are gardeners when it comes to introducing plants that could potentially escape the garden?
Joey Santore: Uh, I mean that’s just what it is. I I grow I grow non-native plants. I have non-native plants that I like. You know, it’s it’s not a religion, the native planting, but if a garden’s purpose is to provide quality of life improvement to the people who garden, it’s therapeutic to do it and it’s nice to have plants around, or to provide food, right? And also to provide, yeah, life habitat for the life around you. It’s nice to have birds, that’s a quality of life thing. It’s nice to have dragonflies and cool insects that you like seeing in your yard, right? But once I kind of learned, and I learned by default, I was I denied invasion biology for the first five years I was in the plants round. Once I learned just how much pragmatic sense it makes, right? Why am I going to try and grow this thing that didn’t evolve here just because I like the way it looks? It’s a pain in the ass. I’m going to spend the next four years trying to keep it alive. It’s eventually going to die anyway, or it’s going to fucking take over and and end up smothering other things that I want to learn about, right? Literally smothering them. What’s the point? It’s just not it’s the wrong piece for the the wrong machine, right? A different machine, put it in there, right? But if some but, you know, if something’s non-native but not invasive, all invasive plants are non-native, not all non-native plants are invasive. When if something’s not invasive and I just like having it, it makes a nice, uh, whatever. I got these, you know, day of the dead marigolds out in front of my house right now because I like the way they look. I just like the way they look, I like the history, the you know, in Mexico behind them, um, and I got a couple in a pot, but it’s not, you know, my whole yard is all native stuff that evolved there because that’s just what I want to see, and that’s what’s going to grow easiest here. And that’s the habitat that used to be here and got destroyed to put up the parking lots and the consumer farms and all the bullshit everywhere that I hope gets hit with an asteroid some day. So, um, it just is what makes sense to me, and it that brings all the life. I get cool birds in my yard, I get cool insects, and I learn so much by having these things here. If I was just planting what I liked because it makes a pretty flower, who cares where it’s from, it’s from, you know, fucking Mongolia, but it makes a pretty flower and I just like it. Yeah, a little bit of that’s fine, but if that was what the whole garden was, well, what the fuck? Now I’m just another disconnected gedrule that has no fucking context for the land he lives on and no relationship with it, right? I think having a relationship with the land that you live on and the history there is very important.
Sarah Wilson: Yeah, I agree. And I was just thinking back to what you were saying about the sort of invasive plants as well. Honestly, you should definitely come to the UK because there are so many people who would love, I’m sure, to debate you and hear your point of view. But I went to a conference recently and it’s fair to say everybody at the conference came from an ecology background and everybody was completely adamant that there is no such thing as a native plant really, or if there is, it’s such an arguable definition that it’s very difficult to pin down.
Joey Santore: Do they ever leave the UK?
Sarah Wilson: Yeah, some were from, there was a guy there from Australia, you know, they were people who work internationally, and they’re very eminent people. But one of the the arguments they made about kind of invasives in the wider landscape was that you could have something like a Himalayan balsam, for example, which is a plant that kind of colonizes alongside our waterways and is a pain in the arse and it takes over, you know, a habitat that would have otherwise been occupied by a lot of UK native plants. And he was saying, but it provides a function because it’s good for bees, which is fine, but what they were kind of glossing over was the food aspect of it for invertebrate larval stages, for example. And my query with that is, yes, it might be providing an ecosystem function now, but we don’t even know probably the full extent of what the system was before that, because we just don’t have the data, we didn’t study
Joey Santore: So these these are people in academia?
Sarah Wilson: Yeah, yeah.
Joey Santore: That’s mind-blowing. I’ve never heard anything like that before. Yeah, it’s got that would be like pouring salt in my ears, man. I can’t. I don’t know.
Joey Santore: You you don’t encounter that, and maybe, I mean you don’t encounter that in North America, really. You hear I hear it from people that are into permaculture, which bless their hearts, right? They’re into permaculture, they don’t know much about ecology, their whole focus—and I’m not knocking them; I’ve historically thrown a lot of jabs at these people, but I’m sure they’re cool. We don’t have to agree on everything. Um, but they’re coming at plants primarily from what can this plant do for me as a human being, you know, can I eat it, is it medicinal or whatever, and that’s fine. Um, and but I think anybody who anybody I know who wants to learn basic ecology learns this and they see like, wow, what they see how, you know, how disastrous invasive species can be and how it can smother an ecosystem and it can lead to reduced diversity. I, you know, I’ve never heard of anybody in academia really saying the opposite. I don’t know. I mean, academia’s got goofball, whatever, you get people that have been in school for 40 fucking years, anything can happen. Um, you know, it can be its own bubble, but, uh, yeah, that’s wild to me. That’s nuts. I don’t know. I mean, maybe it’s different in the UK because the ecology has historically been so wrecked, maybe I don’t know, you know, I mean, just I don’t know, someone had mentioned that to me, they’re like, oh, yeah, there’s this thing in the UK where they say the you know, a lot of people are saying the because of the long human presence there and all the new plants being brought in constantly all the time, that the the ecosystem isn’t really, you know, intact. There’s nothing it’s nothing compared to what it might have been 40,000 years ago, uh, that people are saying that invasives aren’t I don’t know. I don’t know. I can’t I guess I’ve got nothing to really compare, I’ve never been there, and I’ve got nothing to compare it to, but, um, I mean, Australia, it’s weird to hear if someone from Australia thinking that. I mean, they’ve they’ve had some of the biggest issues with invasive species ever. It’s just so hard for me to not imagine confirmation bias, right? Like someone has the opinion before they have all the information.
Sarah Wilson: Yeah, I mean, I can’t obviously speak for them, but it was disappointing that nobody really challenged them, that that seemed to be the message throughout the two-day conference was, you know, it was that. But you said about permaculture people designing a landscape because it functions for them, and I do feel that there’s a lot of issue around humans because we think what does this plant do for us, what does this environment do for us, and we don’t often acknowledge that it’s all right for an environment just to exist for its own sake and for all the things it’s doing that we don’t even understand. Do you support that view?
Joey Santore: Yeah, I mean that things have a right to exist regardless of whether or not they’re useful to people, and not just a right, but they’re probably very important in some way or another. The I mean that’s what the you the more you learn about an ecosystem and about ecology itself, you realize even things that might seem incredibly boring to you probably have a really important function in an ecosystem, right? So, you know, I don’t know. I mean, I I again, I think it’s this that myopic worldview is what we have to move our species away from, instead of what just what can it do for me, to, you know, what what’s really going on here, what’s the larger picture? And what is it doing for me just by being there that I may not be aware of, right? Is it helping prevent flooding? Is it helping, you know, like mangroves along the coast in tropical areas has been a huge Let’s clear the mangroves because they can’t really do anything with them and they’re ugly and now you get the fucking beach eroding, you get massive storms. I mean, that’s a classic case. Um, yeah, so I mean again, this is just it’s not marks of an intelligent species. It’s not marks of an intelligent, enlightened species or society to just start throwing things away, ripping pieces out of this machine and throwing them away without understanding what they do. Not very smart.
Sarah Wilson: Thanks to Joey for such a lively conversation about plants, ecology, and the importance of understanding the natural world. If you enjoyed today’s episode, you might also like Episode 85, “Invasive Plants with Thomas Jones,” and Episode 97, “Nature’s Best Hope with Doug Tallamy.” You’ll find links to both in the show notes.
Now, I’m delighted to say that this week’s episode is brought to you by Meadow Mania, British wildflower seed experts for over 60 years. If you are stuck for a gift for the gardener in your life, please have a look at their Christmas gift shop.They have a hori-hori knife, which digs, cuts, weeds, and plants, as well as a really lovely gardening apron with pockets for everything. They’ve got Nozawa tools, and they’ve got loads more. And until November the 27th this year, you can get a wildflower collection box free of charge on gift orders over £50. So please do check them out at meadowmania.co.uk.They’ve been lovely enough to sponsor this episode, and it does help keep the lights on here.
And as always, thank you for listening. Next up is Benny with his Insect of the Week.
Benny: The plane tree lace bug, scientific name Corythucha ciliata. So, my insect of the week this week is a true bug, a North American native. The etymology Corythucha, the genus, comes from Greek from korys, meaning helmet, and this is kind of a reference to the unusual hood-like or helmet-like head structure. The second word, ciliata, you may have remember that from biology, ciliated cells, and that comes from Latin, and the direct translation is eyelid or eyelash, and that refers to the kind of the cilia or the fine hairs or bristles. And, uh, I believe it’s the the nymph for the juvenile stages of this species that has those on the outside of its body. So quite good etymology. The plane tree lace bug potentially confusing common name because in America it’s also known as the sycamore lace bug. America, I believe, calls plane tree sycamores, whereas in Europe we’ve got the sycamore tree, which is Acer pseudoplatanus, so it’s a different genus and species altogether. Plane trees, we’ve got mostly in the UK at least, the hybrid of the American sycamore and the oriental, um, plane tree, so we’ve got the hybrid of Platanus orientalis and Platanus occidentalis, the American sycamore,to create the London plane, and we’ve got loads of those all around the streets of London, big monocultures of them in certain streets, which is a concern now that this sap-sucking true bug has arrived. So a lot of the Hemipteran true bugs are either sedge-sucks or sap-suckers—a lot of sap-suckers like an aphid—drawing the sap from the tissue of the plant, in this case the leaf, typically. And what is the concern is that this, um, the species, this true bug is a North American species,and so it’s unlikely to have natural predators here. Now, we could get lucky, they could be generalist, economical wasps that target it and they’re recognized, and birds might, but we are likely to be lacking the natural predators that will be there in in North America. This is the issue when you kind of end up with an vertebrate somewhere else, or across a big ocean.Okay, so it sucks sap from plane trees. Also, uh, fractions of species as well, a little bit on hickory and mulberry, just not as much as Platanus species. This really is a plain plain tree species, but it’s not completely reliant on that. So, it was in Europe first in the 1960s in Italy, and then UK had it. 2006 it turned up in the nursery, a plant nursery in Bedfordshire, but it was sprayed and thought to be eradicable at that point. And then it turned up again 2024 in London, and now we’re recording it quite a bit this year, this summer 2026. So, it’s likely to be everywhere in London soon enough, and I don’t think it’s going to be stopped now. And it’s got two or three generations in a in a season on the continent. So that’s also possible in some of that London with quite a long season and good weather. And the adults overwinter under the bark or in the leaf litter sometimes, and then they’ll lay eggs on the the kind of the emerging leaves in spring. Nymphs can hatch within days and go through five instars or stages before reaching adulthood. Complete life cycle is around 30 to 40 days,depending on the temperature and conditions. How they spread: they’re not very good flyers, so they’ll kind of drift on the wind or they’ll hitchhike on animal fur or human bodies, moving cars wherever they can. So they kind of suck sap from the leaves, create like a bronzed foliage, and that can lead to early leaf drop. Obviously, after many years of this happening to a tree, adding to that equation climate stresses, and you’ve got an increased risk then of other problems, so fungi and disease because of these kind of stress factors. And so you’ve got these huge streets in London of one type of tree, which is a a non-native hybrid. Now you’ve got a non-native pest, so carnage might be coming to one of our most dominant street trees. Um, it is a worry. That’s the worry of monoculture, that’s the worry of non-native trees can give you more problems when something turns up that your wildlife isn’t used to. So I’m not sure if you would have seen one of these these bugs before, but do have a look at an image. I’ll try and post one on Instagram so you can see what it looks like as well. Benny records it is a notifiable species, so don’t just log it on iRecord and iNaturalist. You meant to send it on as well. I can send you the link for that as it is a pest species and notifiable. So an interesting one. This is kind of, um, an example of what my friend the entomologist says: if you move plants on the other side of the world, you get the invertebrates you deserve. And that is what can happen. I have a feeling this species is going to be causing a lot of trouble over the next few years.
Sarah Wilson: You can download or listen to the podcast direct from the website rootsandall.co.uk. Please also check out my Patreon, where you can make a one-off donation or take out a monthly subscription to help support the podcast. Because if you enjoy the show, please help it continue. I also have a GoFundMe where you can make a one-off donation. Even a one-off donation of £1 helps, and I’ll be really grateful for your support. So please go to Patreon or GoFundMe and search for Roots and All Podcast.